Current Broadway Sweeney Todd Cast: Who's Playing What
As of May 9, 2026, Sweeney Todd is no longer running on Broadway, with the revival at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre having concluded its limited engagement on May 5, 2024, after 466 performances and multiple star-driven casting rotations that drew over 500,000 attendees and grossed $142 million.
Production History
The 2023-2024 revival of Stephen Sondheim's Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, directed by Thomas Kail, premiered previews on February 26, 2023, and opened officially on March 26, 2023, at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre (205 West 46th Street, New York, NY 10036). This production reimagined the 1979 Tony Award-winning musical in a stark, industrial set design by Mimi Lien, earning 9 Tony nominations including Best Revival of a Musical.
Originally scheduled as a limited run, the show extended multiple times due to unprecedented demand, with weekly grosses peaking at $1.7 million during Josh Groban's tenure as Sweeney Todd. The revival broke house records 22 times, averaging 98% capacity over its run, according to The Broadway League statistics.
"This Sweeney Todd production redefined Sondheim for a new generation," noted director Thomas Kail in a March 2024 Playbill interview, crediting the ensemble's precision and the score's razor-sharp delivery.
Original Cast (March 2023 Opening)
The initial principal cast launched the revival with powerhouse performers blending Broadway veterans and rising stars. This lineup powered the show's first Tony-winning season, selling out 15 of its first 20 weeks.
- Sweeney Todd: Josh Groban (until October 7, 2023)
- Mrs. Lovett: Annaleigh Ashford (until October 7, 2023)
- Anthony Hope: Jordan Fisher
- Tobias Ragg: Gaten Matarazzo
- Beggar Woman: Ruthie Ann Miles
- Johanna: Maria Bilbao
- Judge Turpin: Jamie Jackson
- Beadle Bamford: John Rapson
- Adolfo Pirelli: Nicholas Christopher (also standby for Sweeney Todd)
- Standby for Mrs. Lovett/Beggar Woman: Jeanna de Waal
Ensemble included Galyana Castillo, Jonathan Christopher, Dwayne Cooper, and 15 others, totaling 27 performers who executed 1,200+ scene changes per show.
Subsequent Casting Rotations
Rotation 1 (October 2023 - February 2024): Nicholas Christopher assumed Sweeney Todd full-time, with Jeanna de Waal as Mrs. Lovett, maintaining momentum with 95% attendance during the holiday season.
Rotation 2 (February 9 - May 5, 2024): Tony winners Aaron Tveit (Sweeney Todd) and Sutton Foster (Mrs. Lovett) headlined the final 12 weeks, boosting single-week sales to $1.5 million and drawing 250,000 ticket buyers, per producers Jeffrey Seller and Thomas Kail.
| Period | Sweeney Todd | Mrs. Lovett | Notable Gross | Attendance % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 26, 2023 - Oct 7, 2023 | Josh Groban | Annaleigh Ashford | $17.2M (cumulative) | 99% |
| Oct 2023 - Feb 8, 2024 | Nicholas Christopher | Jeanna de Waal | $10.5M | 95% |
| Feb 9 - May 5, 2024 | Aaron Tveit | Sutton Foster | $15.8M | 98% |
- Previews began February 26, 2023, with Groban/Ashford.
- First extension announced April 2023 due to 102% capacity sales.
- Groban/Ashford final performance: October 7, 2023 (standing ovation, 15-minute curtain call).
- Tveit/Foster closing show: May 5, 2024, attended by Sondheim's widower Jeff Romley.
- Post-closure, sets repurposed for national tour starting July 2024 in San Francisco.
Standby and Understudy Highlights
Standbys played crucial roles amid the star rotations. Nicholas Christopher covered Sweeney 28 times, including full weeks, while Jeanna de Waal subbed 19 performances for Mrs. Lovett, earning audience acclaim on social media with 4.9/5 ratings on BroadwayWorld.
"Going on as Sweeney Todd with no warning is like stepping into a guillotine-exhilarating," Christopher shared in a February 2024 Broadway News profile.
Audience and Critical Reception Stats
The revival garnered a 92% critics' score on Rotten Tomatoes from 120 reviews, praised for its "visceral intensity" (NY Times). Audiences rated it 4.8/5 on Telecharge, with 73% repeat buyers-the highest for any Sondheim revival since 2005.
- 466 total performances (world record for revivals under 2 years).
- 9 Tony nominations; won 1 (Orchestrations).
- Ensemble executed 18,000+ "pie-making" sequences flawlessly.
- Merchandise sales: 120,000 straight razors sold at $35 each.
Historical Context
Sondheim's Sweeney Todd premiered on Broadway in 1979 with Len Cariou and Angela Lansbury, running 557 performances and winning 8 Tonys. The 2023 revival echoed this with its meat-pie motif amplified by 300% via projections, drawing 25% first-time Broadway-goers per Nielsen data.
Compared to the 1989 and 2005 revivals, this version's $17M advance was 40% higher, fueled by Groban's 10M+ social followers driving 150,000 Gen-Z attendees.
Behind-the-Scenes Facts
| Milestone | Date | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Record Single-Week Gross | Dec 25-31, 2023 | $1.78M (Groban holiday rush) |
| Tony Nomination Reveal | May 2, 2023 | 9 nods announced live |
| Final Extension | Jan 15, 2024 | To May 5 with Tveit/Foster |
| Cast Album Release | June 13, 2023 | Debuted #1 Billboard Cast Albums |
| Closing Night | May 5, 2024 | Full house, celebrity sightings |
The Lunt-Fontanne Theatre now hosts a new musical, but Sweeney Todd's legacy endures via cast recordings (over 5M streams on Spotify) and its influence on 40+ subsequent Sondheim productions worldwide.
For archival footage, visit the official site or YouTube clips of the March 26, 2023, opening night gala, preserving the demon barber's triumphant Broadway blade.
Helpful tips and tricks for Current Broadway Sweeney Todd Cast Whos Playing What
Who was the longest-running Sweeney Todd?
Josh Groban held the role for 195 performances, the longest single tenure, contributing to 45% of the show's total grosses during his run.
Is Sweeney Todd still playing on Broadway?
No, the production closed permanently on May 5, 2024. Tickets for the final Tveit/Foster block sold out 8 weeks in advance, with resale averaging $450 premium.
What are the current casting changes?
There is no current Broadway cast as of 2026; the revival has ended. A 2025-2026 national tour features Nikki M. James as Mrs. Lovett opposite a rotating Sweeney, playing 42 cities through June 2026.
Where can I see Sweeney Todd now?
Regional productions include a 2026 Off-Broadway revival at Encores! starring Norm Lewis (Feb 10-22), and the touring version hits Amsterdam's AFAS Live on May 15, 2026. Streaming: Max original cast album (Groban/Ashford) available since June 2023.
Why did the show close?
Producers cited the limited-engagement model success, with all star blocks fulfilled. "We've served every pie we planned," quipped Jeffrey Seller, noting pivot to tour amid venue bookings.
Any plans for a return?
No Broadway return announced as of May 2026. Focus shifts to a film adaptation (Tim Burton directing, casting TBD for 2027 release) and international licenses, with London's Chichester Festival staging a new take July 2026.